Your Real Estate Market Price & Values Source
1/2
Listing Courtesy Of: Sothebys International Realty, Lisa Larson
Local Realty Services Provided By: Keller Williams NYC
US / NY / New York / Carnegie Hill (3rd-Park-E90-E96) / 133 E 91st Street
Overview
What It'll Cost
Neighborhood
Similar Homes

US / NY / New York / Carnegie Hill (3rd-Park-E90-E96) / 133 E 91st Street
$7,950,000
133 E 91st Street, New York City, NY 10128
3 Beds
4 Baths
4,275 sq ft
.03 ac
US / NY / New York / Carnegie Hill (3rd-Park-E90-E96) / 133 E 91st Street
$7,950,000

133 E 91st Street, New York City, NY 10128

Estimation provided by Keller Williams Realty Inc.
3 Beds
4 Baths
4,275 sq ft
.03 ac
pending
For Sale
Keller Williams Realty Advantage Fair Housing

Property Description

Welcome to 133 East 91st Street, a gorgeous 1901-built townhouse nestled in historic Carnegie Hill on one of its coveted tree-lined blocks, moments from Central Park. Replete with exquisite detailing and impeccably designed to capture the beauty and grace of this celebrated neighborhood, this sun-flooded 4-story home spanning nearly 4,300 square feet has been flawlessly rebuilt and reimagined from top-to-bottom by renowned architect Ben Fuqua. Seamlessly blending restored period details with every modern convenience, nothing has been overlooked in this meticulously reconstructed 3-bedroom, 3 full and 2 half bathroom residence which boasts graciously scaled rooms, soaring ceilings, two fireplaces, brand-new windows and white oak floors throughout, and an enchanting landscaped rear garden. The elegant interiors are complemented by substantial capital upgrades, including eight-zoned central air-conditioning and heating, audio system with in-wall speakers, integrated smart home technology, and a full sprinkler and security system. Additionally, the basement level was excavated several feet down to create significant additional full height living space.

GARDEN FLOOR: Enter through a gated garden forecourt into the welcoming entry mudroom with radiant heated floors and a south facing sitting room complemented by expansive custom designed closets. This full floor leisure space includes the lovely dining room which opens into the eat-in kitchen, which was dug out and lowered to create additional ceiling height. Designed to maximize space and functionality, this masterful kitchen is a chef’s dream, offering an abundance of custom cerise wood cabinetry, large center island, and a suite of top-of-the-line Gaggenau appliances including an induction cooktop, teppanyaki, convection stove, steam oven, and warming drawer. Exit the glass French doors to find the landscaped irrigated garden featuring an epai wood privacy fence and an oversized gas grill with dedicated gas line and nestled amid charming neighboring townhouses and mature trees.

PARLOR FLOOR: Walk up the retained historic stoop and enter the original front door with stained glass transom window, both beautifully restored, to the bright parlor floor with soaring 11’8” ceilings and an stunning carved wooden staircase. The front parlor awash with southern sunlight is currently used as an elegant formal living room with eight-foot windows looking over tree-lined 91st Street. The stately rear library is highlighted by a gas fireplace and marble mantel, artful custom bookcases, and oversized windows showcasing the beauty and serenity of the backyard gardens. A wet bar, butler’s pantry, and a chic powder room complete the parlor floor.

THIRD FLOOR: Just above the parlor level lies two generously scaled bedrooms, both with ensuite bathrooms and outfitted walk-in closets, and separated by a large laundry with full sized vented washer and dryer.

FOURTH FLOOR: The entire top floor houses the luxurious and sundrenched primary suite, boasting 11-foot ceilings, a wood-burning fireplace with draft inducer, a walk-through dressing room boasting an enviable 21 feet of custom closets, and a spa-like bathroom fitted with double sinks, stand-alone soaking tub, walk-in shower, high-end designer fixtures, and radiant heated floors. Completing the top level is a home office complete with a built-in desk and cabinets and overlooking the verdant rear gardens below.

LOWER LEVEL: The basement was dug out several feet to create an additional functional floor of living space. Here you will find a media room replete with home theatre, fitness equipment, and a second powder and laundry room.

Perfectly located and move-in ready, this special home must be seen to be fully appreciated.

Property Details

Compare This Home
Overview
Property Type
Single Family Residence
Property Size
4,275 sq ft
Year Built
1901
Days on Site
144 Days
HVAC
Central Air, Central
Parking
No
What's Your Home Worth ?
Keller Williams Realty, Elite Realtors
2438565

Activity History

VIEWS
1
SAVES
0
SHARES
0
Data provided by Keller Williams Realty, Inc.
Upcoming Open Houses
No open houses are currently scheduled for this property. Don't worry - you can always schedule a tour, or get additional help from your agent.

Estimated Monthly Payment

Purchase Price: $7,950,000
Principal + Interest
$0 (0%)
Property Tax
$0 (0%)
Home Insurance
$0 (0%)
HOA/Condo Fee
$0 (0%)
Mortgage Insurance
$0 (0%)
Purchase Price
$
Purchase price has been changed to something other than the currently listed price.
Down Payment
%
$
Interest Rate
%
Loan Type
Property Tax
%
$
Home Insurance /year
$
HOA/Condo Fees /month
$
Mortgage Insurance /month
$
Credit Score
This calculator is just an estimate. Contact Keller Williams for full and accurate assessment.

Price & Tax History

Date
Event
Price
11/06/2024
Listed
$7,950,000
(+50.71%)
08/12/2014
Sold
$5,275,000
Year
Property Tax
Assessed Value
Assessed Value is a combination of the land and additions.
2024
$64,180
$319,541
Land 171,429 + Additions 148,112
2023
$64,180
(+1.51%)
$319,541
Land 165,767 + Additions 153,774
2022
$63,223
(+2.31%)
$381,480
Land 186,600 + Additions 194,880
2021
$61,793
(+4.69%)
$409,920
Land 186,600 + Additions 223,320
2020
$59,025
$442,200
Land 186,600 + Additions 255,600
The Property History data displayed is obtained from public records and/or MLS feeds from the local jurisdiction in which the applicable property is located. As kw.com cannot guarantee that all public records and MLS data is accurate and error-free, it is important that you contact your agent directly in order to obtain the most up-to-date information available.

Explore Carnegie Hill (3rd-Park-E90-E96)

Go to Neighborhood

market snapshot

$3.42M
Avg. List Price
57
Current Listings
193
Avg. Active Days on Market

Nearby Schools

9/10
P.S. 198 Isador E. Ida Straus
Pre-K-5th Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 13:1
9/10
Lower Manhattan Community Middle School
6th-8th Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 12:1
9/10
J.H.S. 167 Robert F Wagner
6th-8th Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 14:1
10/10
M 260 Clinton School
6th-12th Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 12:1
2/10
The High School For Climate Justice
9th-12th Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 9:1
7/10
N.Y.C. Lab School For Collaborative Studies
9th-12th Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 10:1
Show 1 More
Show Less
N/A
St Agnes Boys High School
N/A Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 16:1
N/A
Calhoun School
N/A Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 5:1
N/A
The Child School
N/A Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 7:1
N/A
Cathedral School
N/A Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 6:1
N/A
Yeshiva Ketana Of Manhattan
N/A Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 9:1
N/A
Beit Rabban
N/A Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio: 3:1
Show 95 More
Show Less
Disclaimer: This information is provided by Precisely and subject to change. Please check the applicable school district.

Transit & Commute

Estimated commute times from Carnegie Hill (3rd-Park-E90-E96)
76%
Car-Dependent Walkable Very Walkable
What's Your Home Worth ?
Keller Williams Realty, Elite Realtors
2438565

Similar Properties

Properties with similar features, attributes, and price to this current listing
Featured Properties

Nearby Properties

Nearest properties to this current listing
Sourced By:
Broker disclaimer logo

MLS Source Origin: Real Estate Board of New York

Equal Housing Opportunity. Information last updated on 3/30/2025, 8:10:33 PM EST. Listing data is derived in whole or in part from the Real Estate Board of New York MLS IDX and is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use only. Dimensions are approximate and not guaranteed. All data should be independently verified. Copyright 2025 Real Estate Board of New York MLS, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Managed services by Smarter Agent

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. For more info, read our Cookie Policy. By clicking “Accept” or continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.